Mayflower Voyage 1620: Pilgrims, Compact, and Democracy’s Roots

The Mayflower’s Historic Voyage

In September 1620, the Mayflower, a modest English merchant ship, set sail from Plymouth, England, carrying 102 passengers bound for the New World. These passengers, often referred to as Pilgrims, included religious Separatists seeking freedom from the Church of England, as well as merchants, craftsmen, and others, collectively known as “Strangers,” seeking economic opportunities. The ship’s journey, fraught with peril, marked a pivotal moment in history, establishing Plymouth Colony in what is now Massachusetts and laying an early foundation for American democracy through the Mayflower Compact.

The Mayflower Compact: Original Content

The Mayflower Compact, signed on November 11, 1620 (Old Style; November 21, New Style), was a brief but groundbreaking document that established a framework for self-governance among the settlers. It was drafted to maintain order and unity after the ship landed off-course at Cape Cod, outside the jurisdiction of the Virginia Company’s charter. The original document does not survive, but its text is preserved in Mourt’s Relation (1622) and William Bradford’s Of Plymouth Plantation. Below is the text as it appears in Mourt’s Relation (modernized spelling for clarity):

” In the name of God, Amen. We, whose names are underwritten, the loyal subjects of our dread Sovereign Lord King James, by the Grace of God, of Great Britain, France, and Ireland, King, Defender of the Faith, &c. Having undertaken, for the Glory of God, and Advancement of the Christian Faith, and the Honour of our King and Country, a Voyage to plant the first Colony in the northern Parts of Virginia; Do by these Presents, solemnly and mutually, in the Presence of God and one another, covenant and combine ourselves together into a civil Body Politick, for our better Ordering and Preservation, and Furtherance of the Ends aforesaid: And by Virtue hereof do enact, constitute, and frame, such just and equal Laws, Ordinances, Acts, Constitutions, and Offices, from time to time, as shall be thought most meet and convenient for the general Good of the Colony; unto which we promise all due Submission and Obedience. In witness whereof we have hereunto subscribed our names at Cape Cod the eleventh of November, in the Reign of our Sovereign Lord King James, of England, France, and Ireland, the eighteenth, and of Scotland the fifty-fourth, Anno Domini; 1620. ” – MAYFLOWER COMPACT

The Compact was signed by 41 adult male passengers, establishing a “civil Body Politick” to govern the colony through majority rule and mutual consent, a significant step toward democratic governance.

The Role of Democracy in Today’s World

The Mayflower Compact is often cited as an early precursor to modern democracy, introducing the principle of governance by consent of the governed. Today, democracy remains a cornerstone of global governance, emphasizing individual rights, rule of law, and collective decision-making. It fosters political stability, protects freedoms, and encourages civic participation, though its implementation varies widely.Democracy’s role in the modern world includes:

• Empowering Citizens: Democratic systems allow individuals to elect representatives, influence policies, and hold governments accountable through voting and free expression.
• Promoting Equality: Democracies strive to uphold equal rights, though challenges like systemic inequality and voter suppression persist.
• Global Influence: Democratic nations often lead in international diplomacy, human rights advocacy, and economic cooperation, though authoritarian regimes challenge this influence.
• Challenges: Issues like misinformation, political polarization, and declining trust in institutions threaten democratic integrity in many countries.

The Mayflower Compact’s emphasis on collective agreement and self-governance resonates in modern democratic principles, influencing documents like the U.S. Constitution and inspiring global democratic movements.

List of Democratic Countries

As of 2025, democratic countries span various forms, including liberal democracies, parliamentary democracies, and presidential democracies. Based on indices like the Democracy Index by the Economist Intelligence Unit (2024), the following are examples of countries classified as full or flawed democracies (note: this is not exhaustive, as classifications may vary):Full Democracies (high levels of civil liberties and political participation):

• Norway
• New Zealand
• Iceland
• Sweden
• Finland
• Denmark
• Canada
• Australia
• Switzerland
• Netherlands
• Germany
• United Kingdom
• Japan
• South Korea
• United States (flawed in some indices due to polarization)

Flawed Democracies (democratic structures with notable weaknesses):

• India
• Brazil
• South Africa
• Mexico
• Philippines
• Indonesia
• Poland
• Italy
• France
• Spain

This list is illustrative; over 80 countries have some form of democratic governance, though quality varies. Authoritarian regimes, hybrid systems, and monarchies also exist, complicating global democratic landscapes.

Types of Governments Today

Modern governments take various forms, reflecting cultural, historical, and political contexts. The main types include:

• Democracy: Power derives from the people via elections (e.g., United States, India). Subtypes include:
  • Parliamentary Democracy: Executive power stems from the legislature (e.g., United Kingdom, Germany).
  • Presidential Democracy: Separate executive and legislative branches (e.g., United States, Brazil).
• Monarchy: Ruled by a king or queen, either absolute (e.g., Saudi Arabia) or constitutional (e.g., United Kingdom, Japan).
• Authoritarian: Centralized control with limited political freedoms (e.g., China, North Korea).
• Theocracy: Governance based on religious principles (e.g., Iran, Vatican City).
• Oligarchy: Power held by a small elite (e.g., some hybrid regimes like Russia).
• Federal Republic: Power shared between central and regional governments (e.g., Germany, United States).
• Unitary State: Centralized power with limited regional autonomy (e.g., France, Japan).
• Hybrid Regimes: Combine democratic and authoritarian elements (e.g., Turkey, Venezuela).

These systems often overlap, and their effectiveness depends on implementation, cultural context, and public trust.

Mayflower Ship Design

The Mayflower was a square-rigged merchant ship, typical of early 17th-century English vessels. While no detailed blueprints survive, marine archaeologists estimate:

• Size and Weight: Approximately 180 tons, 90 feet (27 meters) long, and 25 feet (7.6 meters) wide.
• Structure: Three masts with square sails, a high forecastle, and a sterncastle. The main deck was about 75 by 20 feet, with cramped cabins below.
• Living Conditions: Passengers lived in the dark, cold cargo decks below the crew’s quarters, with limited space (less than a single bed per person). There was no privy; passengers used buckets as chamber pots.
• Armament: Heavily armed for defense, carrying a minion cannon (1,200 pounds, firing 3.5-pound cannonballs), a saker cannon (800 pounds), and smaller base cannons.
• Fate: The ship’s ultimate fate is unknown, but some historians suggest its timber was used to build a barn in Jordans, England. A replica, Mayflower II, was built in 1957 and sailed to Massachusetts.

The ship’s sturdy design allowed it to withstand the treacherous Atlantic crossing, though conditions were harsh for passengers.

The Three-Month Journey: Details

The Mayflower’s journey lasted 66 days, from September 6 to November 11, 1620, covering approximately 2,750 miles across the Atlantic. Here are key details:

• Departure: The Mayflower set sail from Plymouth, England, on September 6, 1620, after two failed attempts with the leaky Speedwell. It carried 102 passengers and about 30 crew, led by Captain Christopher Jones.
• Conditions: The voyage was grueling, with rough seas and storms. A main beam cracked mid-journey, repaired with a “great iron screw” brought by passengers. Passengers endured cramped, unsanitary conditions, with many suffering seasickness.
• Incidents: John Howland was swept overboard during a storm but was rescued after grabbing a rope. One sailor died, reportedly due to divine punishment for mocking passengers. One passenger, William Butten, died near the journey’s end.
• Births: Two babies were born: Oceanus Hopkins during the voyage and Peregrine White after anchoring at Cape Cod.
• Arrival: On November 11, 1620, the Mayflower anchored at Provincetown Harbor, Cape Cod, far north of its intended destination near the Hudson River. Dangerous shoals prevented further travel south. After exploration, the settlers moved to Plymouth Harbor on December 21, 1620.
• Aftermath: The ship remained in port until April 1621, serving as shelter during the brutal first winter, when half the passengers died. It returned to England on April 5, 1621.

The journey tested the passengers’ resilience, shaping their determination to establish a new society.

Names and Professions of the 41 Mayflower Compact Signers

The Mayflower Compact was signed by 41 adult male passengers, including Separatists, merchants, craftsmen, and servants. Below is the list of signers with their known or inferred professions, based on historical records like William Bradford’s writings and MayflowerHistory.com.

1. John Carver – Merchant, Separatist leader, first governor of Plymouth Colony.
2. William Bradford – Separatist leader, second governor, historian.
3. Edward Winslow – Separatist, diplomat, later governor.
4. William Brewster – Separatist elder, preacher, printer.
5. Isaac Allerton – Merchant, Separatist, assistant governor.
6. Myles Standish – Military advisor, captain.
7. John Alden – Cooper (barrel-maker), hired crewman.
8. Samuel Fuller – Physician, deacon, Separatist.
9. Christopher Martin – Merchant, Virginia Company representative (died 1621).
10. William Mullins – Shoemaker, merchant (died 1621).
11. William White – Separatist (died 1621).
12. Richard Warren – Merchant.
13. John Howland – Servant to John Carver, later prominent colonist.
14. Stephen Hopkins – Merchant, tanner, experienced colonist (previously at Jamestown).
15. Edward Tilley – Separatist (died 1621).
16. John Tilley – Separatist (died 1621).
17. Francis Cooke – Separatist, woolcomber.
18. Thomas Rogers – Separatist, camlet merchant (died 1621).
19. Thomas Tinker – Separatist, wood sawyer (died 1621).
20. John Ridgdale – Separatist (died 1621).
21. Edward Fuller – Separatist (died 1621).
22. John Turner – Separatist (died 1621).
23. Francis Eaton – Carpenter.
24. James Chilton – Separatist, tailor (died 1621).
25. John Crackston – Separatist (died 1621).
26. John Billington – Non-Separatist, likely laborer.
27. Moses Fletcher – Separatist, blacksmith (died 1621).
28. John Goodman – Separatist (died 1621).
29. Degory Priest – Separatist, hatter (died 1621).
30. Thomas Williams – Separatist (died 1621).
31. Gilbert Winslow – Non-Separatist, possibly merchant, brother of Edward Winslow.
32. Edmund Margesson – Non-Separatist, possibly merchant (died 1621).
33. Peter Browne – Non-Separatist, likely laborer.
34. Richard Bitteridge – Non-Separatist (died 1621).
35. George Soule – Servant to Edward Winslow.
36. Richard Clarke – Non-Separatist (died 1621).
37. Richard Gardiner – Non-Separatist, possibly sailor.
38. John Allerton – Seaman, hired laborer (died 1621).
39. Thomas English – Seaman, hired for shallop work (died 1621).
40. Edward Dotey – Servant to Stephen Hopkins.
41. Edward Leister – Servant to Stephen Hopkins.

Note: Professions are based on historical records, but some are inferred due to limited documentation. Many Separatists had trade skills, while “Strangers” included laborers and servants. Those marked as dying in 1621 succumbed during the first winter.

British King Who Permitted the Colony

The British monarch who granted permission for the Pilgrims to establish a colony was King James I (reigned 1603–1625). The Separatists secured a patent from the Virginia Company, authorized by the king, to settle near the Hudson River. The patent was issued to John Pierce on February 2, 1620, with the condition that the settlers “carry themselves peaceably.” Despite landing outside the Virginia Company’s jurisdiction, the settlers affirmed their loyalty to King James I in the Mayflower Compact.

John Howland: The Passenger Thrown Overboard and His Descendants

One of the most dramatic incidents during the Mayflower’s voyage involved John Howland, a young indentured servant to Governor John Carver, who was swept overboard during a violent storm. According to William Bradford’s account in Of Plymouth Plantation, during a “mighty storm” in the North Atlantic, Howland ventured onto the main deck, possibly seeking fresh air, and was thrown into the sea by a wave. Miraculously, he grabbed a topsail halyard trailing in the water, holding on despite being submerged “sundry fathoms” under the surface. The crew used a boat hook to pull him back aboard, saving his life. Though he fell ill briefly, Howland recovered and lived to become a prominent figure in Plymouth Colony.

Howland, born around 1599 in Fenstanton, Huntingdonshire, England, was about 21 during the voyage. After the deaths of John Carver and his wife in 1621, Howland became a freeman and possibly inherited part of their estate. He married fellow passenger Elizabeth Tilley, daughter of John and Joan Tilley, around 1624. Both of Elizabeth’s parents died during the first winter, leaving her an orphan under Carver’s care, and later Howland’s ward. The couple settled in Plymouth, later moving to Rocky Nook (now Kingston), and had ten children: Desire, John, Hope, Elizabeth, Lydia, Hannah, Joseph, Jabez, Ruth, and Isaac, all of whom survived to adulthood.

John Howland’s survival was consequential, as he and Elizabeth founded one of the largest Mayflower families, with an estimated 2 million descendants in the United States alone, according to the General Society of Mayflower Descendants. Notable descendants include:

• U.S. Presidents: Franklin D. Roosevelt, George H.W. Bush, and George W. Bush.
• First Lady: Edith Roosevelt (wife of Theodore Roosevelt).
• Actors: Humphrey Bogart, Christopher Lloyd, and the Baldwin brothers (Alec, Stephen, Billy, and Danny).
• Other Figures: Julia Child, Norman Rockwell, and Gail Adams, editor of The Howland Quarterly.

Howland served as an assistant governor (1633–1635), deputy to the Plymouth General Court (1641–1655, 1658), and head of the Kennebec trading post until 1634. He died in 1672 at about 80, outliving most male passengers except George Soule, John Alden, John Cooke, and Richard More. Elizabeth died in 1687. Their legacy endures through the Pilgrim John Howland Society, which owns part of their Rocky Nook land, and a monument on Burial Hill in Plymouth, erected in 1897.

The incident, immortalized in P.J. Lynch’s book The Boy Who Fell Off the Mayflower, or John Howland’s Good Fortune, underscores Howland’s resilience and the providential nature of his survival, which allowed his extensive lineage to shape American history.

Conclusion

The Mayflower’s voyage and the signing of the Mayflower Compact were pivotal moments in the history of self-governance. The Compact’s principles of mutual consent and majority rule laid a foundation for American democracy, influencing modern governance worldwide.

The ship’s design and the grueling three-month journey, marked by events like John Howland’s near-death experience, highlight the resilience of the 102 passengers, whose legacy endures in the millions of descendants and the democratic ideals they helped inspire.

---